Elements of a Good Experiment
Equipment review and introductions may include
Writing a Paper
Text: You will be using a free, pdf version of a text that is under development. Please do not distribute the text. Your comments, corrections, and other feedback will be warmly received. There will also be class notes, handouts, and web resource materials. It is absolutely vital that you take comprehensive notes during the class.
This semester is your opportunity to develop your physical intuition in the context of investigating a problem. You will get to formally state the problem, design and construct the investigation, analyze the data, draw appropriate conclusions and communicate the results. In all respects a more polished performance is required of you in this class than you have had to demonstrate in the past. This course represents a transition for you, from student to professional. You need to develop a professional sense of responsibility for the work you produce, and for the process of producing it. Much of the evaluation of your work (by me) is from a professional perspective. Think of yourselves as doing work for pay, and I am the boss. Don't turn in a student product, turn in a professional one.
Please communicate your questions, comments, and problems to me. I am pleased to see you any time you can drop in. Please leave me a note if you can't find me.
It is your responsibility to learn—to do the work using available resources, taking responsibility for finding the knowledge and equipment you need. You get to work in groups and alone. Take this opportunity to show to everyone that you can handle the responsibility. Historically, the biggest problem encountered by students in this course is poor time management. You are given some freedom to schedule your assault on the problem—don't make bad choices with this freedom.
Be courteous to others. We have limited space and equipment, so don't necessarily expect to set up an experiment and have sole use of the equipment and space for more than a couple of days. You may need to coordinate with your classmates for access to some equipment. There may be times when courtesy should be extended with regard to opening the door and turning on lights. You are expected to put equipment away and otherwise keep the experiment areas clean and tidy.
Preparation for the Course
Either Modern Physics (phys230) or Climate (phys225) are a prerequisite for this course. You will need to enter the course with a working knowledge of the physics and mathematics at that level. Laboratory experiences in physics 111/112 are a valuable knowledge and experience base for this course. Review your laboratory experience. Look over old reports to identify skills you need. Of course by now you should have completed English 110. If you haven't, then don't take this course. Finish English first.
I also assume that you have computer skills, including email, using the web, word processing, Mathematica, spread sheets, and other generic, scientific computer tools. We will enhance your skills with all of these.
We will have formal classroom time, especially early in the semester. It is important that you apply your attention to these presentations as they will be vital to your experiments. Students will be required to pick a professional track—physics, astronomy, or meteorology. While everyone is exposed to the same two options for the first experiment, there are computational, equipment and write-up differences between the professions. This will be especially important on subsequent experiments, which tend to be more closely connected to your professional goals.
There will be two phases to the course. They are somewhat co-mingled
I may allow you to work in groups of up to three, although after the first experiment, you will ordinarily work alone. In no case will you work with any specific individual on more than two of your experiments. I reserve the right to restrict your choice of partners, and I may even require you to work alone. This does not mean that you cannot engage in collegial discussions with classmates about experiments.
Absences and Tardiness
On the occasions we have formal lecture or other classroom time you are responsible for the material presented. Contact a classmate for the notes. If you need to document absences, please talk with me first. The formal approach is
To document an absence for any class
Preparing to do an Experiment
There are several steps to take before you actually do an experiment.
You will maintain a notebook of your lab experience. It may be hard copy hand written, or an on-line version. This is the 21st century, and many research organizations do it electronically. In either case, it is an up to date diary of your lab work. I will need to be given unfettered access to the on-line version. With either approach, it should contain dates, names, times, equipment lists, diagrams, raw data, musings, ideas, sketches, graphs, data, casual observations... The lab notebook is the basis for your lab report, which should contain nothing that isn't in the notebook, at least rudimentarily. It should be decipherable by your colleagues, but is intended to be a working document, not a finished product. I will examine these notebooks from time to time without notice.
Here are some guidelines:
(Obviously, some are only relevant to hard-copy notebooks)
The written products in this class are intended to help you learn to do professional, journal style articles. Communications to the professional community via journals are very different from other written products, for example, a "lab report" in most other lab classes has a very different audience and intention than the articles you write in this class. Similarly for a final grant report or final project report to a funding agency. Each has its purpose and audience, and are consequently very different from one another. It is vital that you understand the purpose, audience, format, and editorial standards for any written product.
Each student will produce and submit their own report, even though you may do the experiment as a group. While you may work closely together on the experiment, each student writes up their own report, in the appropriate format (i.e., using the LaTeX template suitable to their profession), and each student should be completely competent in the details of data manipulation and analysis. Reports are expected to meet the highest editorial and scientific standards. Pretend it is being submitted to a refereed journal for publication and that your job is on the line. The details of your format are dictated by those used in a journal you choose which is consistent with your career goals. The term "lab report" is somewhat of a misnomer, as you turn in a lab notebook, and your formal write-up is more of a journal submission format.
These formal reports are the focal point of your work. The experiment isn't worth doing unless its results are communicated to others. A generic, everything is OK, no significant errors, good layout, adequately conducted, reasonable conclusion lab will get you "B". Subtlety, insight, and cleverness can get you more. Lab reports are written up individually, even though experiments may be conducted as a group. It is inappropriate (i.e., it is considered academic dishonesty) to pass lab reports down to students in future classes, or to get them from previous classes.
The editorial guidelines used by the American Physical Society or American Astronomical Society will generally be followed unless you convince me that you should follow the guidelines of another organization. If your career goals and academic path are consistent with your case it will likely be fine with me. See example papers in journals such as Physical Review, or check out their online style guide, or the Astrophysics style guide
Reports will ordinarily contain
The Checklist— Pitfalls, Tips, and Hints...
In addition to the guidelines above, the following will be considered when assigning a grade to your report.
You will make oral presentations in several ways. On occasion you will be asked to give a 1-2 minute status report on your current experiment. This will likely be without notice. Finally, you will give a seven minute formal presentation, probably, but not necessarily, on your third experiment.
The formal presentation will be given during a final exam period for our class. The talks follow a standard presentation format used at scientific meetings. The talks will be seven minutes long (+/- 1 min), and use suitable, professional-quality visual aids. For a really good primer, see the MIT Sample. Another good set of tips for scientific talks.
The due dates above for things up to and including experiment 2 are subject to change a little, but there will be suitable notice. Late assignments may be accepted (at my whim), but will ordinarily be penalized, more so each day they are late. It is especially important that you turn in the first write-ups on time so you can benefit from peer editing.
The accumulation of grades is as follows. We do three experiments. For experiments one and two you submit an original lab report, then we do some editing, and you submit a revised version. The original and its revision are each graded, and carry the same weight. The third experiment is a one-shot effort—no revision. In the overall grading scheme the first experiment carries a weight of 2, the second a weight of 4, and the third a weight of 6.
I assign letter grades to papers, lab notebooks, and talks. The letter grade is assigned a number as in the College's grading scheme (A=4.0, A- = 3.7...). Proficiency exercises and quizzes are graded on a 10-point scale, which is rescaled to a 4.0 scale by dividing by 2.5. The weighted average is calculated to determine the final grade. Below are the relative weights of the pieces of your semester grade.
|Quizzes and proficiency exercises||15%|
|Total||100% of course grade|
Course Pre/Co-requisites: phys230, or phys225 or permissionLearning Objectives —
Accommodations for Students with Disabilities —
Any student eligible for and needing accommodations because of a disability is requested to contact me as soon as practical or as soon as you have been approved for services so that reasonable accommodations can be arranged. I'm easy to get along with. The Center for Disability Services is the resource place.
Academic Integrity —
It is expected that you will adhere to the university's honor code and student code of conduct, as can be found in the Student Handbook